Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing: Pros, Cons & Cost Comparison

When it comes to roofing systems for your home, there are a range of factors to consider. These include preference, aesthetic, cost, durability, longevity, and the overall protection afforded. Many roofing decisions come down to metal vs. asphalt, and each option comes with its own pros and cons, which include the matter of cost. If you’re in the market for new roofing, our seasoned Westmoreland County roofing specialists at KSL Roofing and Remodeling are well prepared to help.

The Pros and Cons of Asphalt and Metal Roofs

Both metal and asphalt roofs can be excellent options, but there are pros and cons associated with each.

Asphalt Roofing

Asphalt roofing is the most common, the most versatile, and the most cost-effective roofing system out there. Ease of installation, maintenance, and repair is a major plus when it comes to asphalt shingles. Additionally, most asphalt shingles have a Class A rating in terms of fire resistance, which means they offer very good fire protection.

While asphalt tiles come in many different varieties, most asphalt roofs look very similar to one another. This can be a pro or a con depending on your unique taste. It’s also important to note that there are pricier asphalt options that mimic the look of other roofing materials like slate, clay, and cedar.

When it comes to the downside of asphalt roofing, a primary concern is its longevity. Asphalt tiles have a relatively thin construction, which can rip and tear in response to bad weather. Further, they are vulnerable to wind uplift and are not as environmentally friendly as metal roofing is.

Standard asphalt roofs that use 3-tab shingles also have a shorter life expectancy than metal roofs do, and they generally require replacement after 10 to 20 years. Pricier varieties, however, can last significantly longer.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing has a lot to recommend it, but consumers pay for all the related benefits.

The Pros

Consider all the following primary pros associated with metal roofing:

• Metal roofing offers a wide range of options, including in relation to the kind of metal used and to the many colorways and designs available.
• Metal roofs are incredibly durable and hold up well even under severe conditions like Pennsylvania’s harsh weather.
• Metal roofing offers superior resistance to impact, such as from hail.
• Metal roofs can last from 40 to 80 years, which far outpaces the lifespan of asphalt roofs.
• Metal roofs are energy efficient, and because they are recyclable and are often made of recycled metal, they’re an environmentally friendly option.
• Metal roofs exceed the Class A fire rating by not only offering excellent fire resistance but also being noncombustible.

The Cons

The primary cons of metal roofing are the higher price tag and the fact that they can be significantly louder in storms. In addition, because metal roofs expand and contract in response to significant changes in temperature, regular maintenance is generally required.

The Cost Differential

You can expect to pay two to three times more for a metal roof than you would for an asphalt roof when you compare the midrange for each. The fact that metal roofs tend to last far longer, however, can translate to serious savings over time. Ultimately, you’ll need to balance the pros and cons of each option in relation to your needs, budget, and preferences in order to make the right choice for you.

Call Our Experienced Westmoreland County Roofing Pros Today

Our seasoned Westmoreland County roofing professionals at KSL Roofing and Remodeling have the expertise and knowledge to help you make roofing decisions with confidence. Learn more by contacting us online or giving us a call at 724-539-1200 today.